Posts

Where We Go To Church

It turns out that Americans do not have a one-size-fits-all approach to our preferred faith community. some like large churches; others like small. some prefer contemporary services; others prefer more traditional services. Some move to more conservative churches; others moved to more liberal churches. Here is the report from the Christian Post : In a study of over 1,000 American adults, released Monday by Ellison Research, 69 percent of all Americans who currently attend worship services have attended more than one place of worship - which includes churches, temples, or houses of worship - as an adult. Only 31 percent say their current place of worship is the only one they have regularly attended since age 18. When changing where they worship, not all opt for a bigger congregation or a more contemporary worship style. When choosing size, Americans are nearly evenly divided between a larger or smaller congregation. Forty-three percent of American Protestants have moved to a larger cong...

United Methodists and Teachers on Evolution in the Classroom

Image
Two unrelated stories worth noting. First, the United Methodist Church has adopted a resolution rejecting the teaching of creationism and "Intelligent Design" as science: The United Methodist Church passed a resolution at its recent General Conference opposing the teaching of Creation Science and Intelligent Design in public schools. The statement, passed during a 10-day conference in Fort Worth, Texas, that ended May 2, put the denomination on record "as opposing the introduction of any faith-based theories such as Creationism or Intelligent Design into the science curriculum of our public schools." "Creationism and Intelligent Design are appropriate topics in public education classes such as comparative religion, literature, or philosophy since scientific method incorporates critical thinking processes," said the resolution adopted by a vote of 508 to 323. "All truth is God’s truth. The promotion of religion or any particular religion in the publi...

The Ethics of Climate Change

John Broome, Professor of Moral Philosophy at the University of Oxford and previously a professor of economics at the University of Bristol, has a very interesting analysis of the ethics of climate change in the Scientific American . the ethical issue he focuses on this this: future generations will benefit the most from the current generation's efforts to stop climate change, but the evidence is that future generations will be richer. As any economist will tell you, in doing a cost-benefit analysis, a critical factor is the selection of the discount rate. As I previously noted , the Stern Report did an economic analysis that set the discount rate very low. Broome explains why this makes sense from a moral point of view. It is a long article. Here are some excerpts: Climate change raises a number of ethical questions. How should we—all of us living today—evaluate the well-being of future generations, given that they are likely to have more material goods than we do? Many people, s...

Bultmann versus Wright on the Resurection

I ran across a wonderful blog on theology, Rain and Rhinoceros , by Ry Siggelkow, an M.A. student in theology at the Saint Paul Seminary School of Divinity at the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul Minnesota. One of his most interesting recent posts is comparing the differing views of Rudolf Bultmann and N.T. Wright on whether historical critical methods have any bearing on the historical truth of the resurrection. Bultmann thought that the resurrection was an eschatological event beyond the realm of historical study: One of the most important and controversial responses to the challenge of modern biblical criticism was Rudolf Bultmann’s demythologizing project. Bultmann’s work takes for granted that modern biblical scholarship and modern science have effectively dismantled the biblical worldview. For modern man, according to Bultmann, belief in a three-level universe, demons, angels, the miraculous, and resurrected bodies, is akin to belief in a flat earth, leprechauns, and unicorns...

Explaining Progressive Theology to Atheists

Professor James McGrath knows a lot more about theology than I do. It also appears that his Christianity is bit less orthodox than me. (Not that there is anything wrong with that!) In the past week there has been a very interesting dialogue on several blogs between McGrath (and other progressive Christians) and some atheists about progressive theology. McGrath tries to explain the necessity to use metaphor to talk about the ultimate. The atheists keep telling him to speak more plainly. Actually, it is a great dialogue. And a great tutorial about som erecent theologians to boot. Here is a sample of McGrath's efforts to explain progressive theology: Paul Tillich, one of the great and extremely influential theologians of the 20th century, spoke of God as Being itself rather than "a being". In other words, the discussion is not about a certain type of being (immoral, invisible, omniscient and omnipotent and presumably omnivorous as well) that exists in the universe, whether h...

More on Prince Caspian

Image
Here is a round-up of blogger reviews of Prince Caspian. Ross Douthat has mixed feelings, noting that this was the weakest of the Narnia series: I'm still sorting through my own thoughts before I buckle down to write my NR review, but after spending some time marinating in the Narniaphile reaction , I think that to the extent I liked the movie, it was largely for the same reasons as Frederica Mathewes-Greene : The filmmakers took what is easily the weakest of the Narnia novels, rejiggered the narrative and altered the plot, and produced an entertaining, swashbuckling medieval war movie set against a Narnian backdrop. To the extent that I disliked the movie, meanwhile, it was for the same reasons as Steven Greydanus : In the course of making a poorly-constructed book into an entertaining fantasy adventure, the filmmakers largely purged the original story of its most distinctive thematic elements, and the results owe more to Braveheart and Lord of the Rings, in certain ways, than t...

More on "They Don't Get It"

I blogged a few days ago about the old guard right wing of the Evangelical movement's efforts to deny climate change. David Roberts had an interesting take on this group--and why they are fighting so hard against reality: We've written a great deal on Grist about the split in the evangelical leadership between those who recognize the danger of global warming and those who don't. The former includes lots of younger churchgoers who want to broaden the church's mandate beyond abortion and homosexuality , taking on poverty and environmental issues and asserting the church's independence from the Republican party. The latter group, the old guard , is filled with people who have become extremely rich and politically powerful through their association with the Republican party, and are keen to preserve the status quo. Their role is to keep the religious wing of the Republican base in line by stoking (but never resolving) the culture war, providing ground troops and votes...

Are We Too Divided?

Yesterday's New York Times Book Review reviewed a very interesting book, The Big Sort: Why the Clustering of Like-Minded America Is Tearing Us Apart , that argues that we are living in many quite homogeneous communities, and that this is hurting our political life. Here is how the reviewer describes the Book: Over the last decade, as 100 million Americans have moved from one place to another, they’ve clustered in increasingly homogeneous communities. This is where “The Big Sort,” which grew out of a series of articles that Bishop, formerly a reporter at The Austin American-Statesman, wrote with Robert Cushing, a retired sociologist and statistician from the University of Texas, is both wonkiest and most original. Working with a team of collaborators (including Richard Florida, the author of “The Rise of the Creative Class”), Bishop and Cushing swam around in different sets of data — voting records; I.R.S. income figures; patent filings; poll numbers from advertising firms — to fig...

Prince Caspian

I posted this at the Lead earlier today, but thought it would be of interest to readers here as well : The film adaptation of C.S. Lewis' Prince Caspian , part of the Narnia series of children's books, was released to somewhat mixed but largely positive reviews. Here is Christianity Today 's take: Lewis wanted to give his readers—including Christians who had unthinkingly bought into modernity—a taste of the spiritual realm that animates our physical world. And since he believed that the pagan, pre-Christian man had a greater aptitude for the spiritual realm, and was thus easier to convert, than the secular, post-Christian man, Lewis wrote the Narnia books to introduce his readers to a "baptized" form of paganism. Nowhere is this more explicit than in the original book version of Prince Caspian , in which the Christ-figure Aslan literally dances with the Greco-Roman god Bacchus. But Adamson and his co-writers, Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely, show no inter...

Why is There Pain?

Utilitarian focused philosopher Peter Singer comes back to the oldest of questions: why does God allow pain. Not much new here, but it does offer a backdrop for discussion and thought. Here are some highlights: Do we live in a world that was created by a god who is all-powerful, all-knowing, and all good? Christians think we do. Yet a powerful reason for doubting this confronts us every day: the world contains a vast amount of pain and suffering. If God is all-knowing, he knows how much suffering there is. If he is all-powerful, he could have created a world without so much of it - and he would have done so if he were all good. Christians usually respond that God bestowed on us the gift of free will, and hence is not responsible for the evil we do. But this reply fails to deal with the suffering of those who drown in floods, are burned alive in forest fires caused by lightning, or die of hunger or thirst during a drought. Christians sometimes attempt to explain this suffering by saying...

Pope versus Sullivan on Gay Marriage

The Pope issued a statement that seems to have been a reaction to this week's decision on same sex marriage: The union of love, based on matrimony between a man and a woman, which makes up the family, represents a good for all society that can not be substituted by, confused with, or compared to other types of unions," he said. The pope also spoke of the inalienable rights of the traditional family, "founded on matrimony between a man and a woman, to be the natural cradle of human life". Andrew Sullivan has a very interesting response, which makes the essential point that we need to distinguish what is reasonable and appropriate in deciding the religious distinctions among relationships versus what civil law should recognize: Actually, I agree with this in large part. I revere heterosexual unions and heterosexual marriage. When such a union produces biological children, it also reaches mystical, powerful heights of human experience. I wouldn't want it substitute...

New Study: Climate and Greenhouse Gases Are Linked

One of the most important sources of data about the correlation between greenhouse gases (like methane and carbon dioxide) and global warming has been core samples from the ice in Antarctica. Tiny bubble of gas are dropped in the ice and they offer evidence of the composition of the atmosphere over thousands of years. Earlier this week, Nature published a study of ice core date going back about 800,000 years. Critical to the current debate on climate change, there is a strong correlation between greenhouse gases and temperature going that far back: The newest analysis of trace gases trapped in Antarctic ice cores now provide a reasonable view of greenhouse gas concentrations as much as 800,000 years into the past, and are further confirming the link between greenhouse gas levels and global warming, scientists reported May 14 in the journal Nature. They also show that during that entire period of time, there have never been concentrations of carbon dioxide and methane as high as the cu...

Will California voters undue the Supreme Court decision

Kevin Drum does an analysis of trends in polling data to suggest that an effort to undue the California Supreme Court decision on same sex marriage at the ballot box will be closer than people seem to understand: Here's a very crude cut at an answer. Lots of polls have been done over the years about attitudes toward gays, and they all show a similar trend: people have become more gay friendly at the rate of about 1% per year. Here are some examples from Karlyn Bowman's 2006 roundup of historical poll data: Same-sex relations "not wrong": increased from 11% to 31% between 1973 and 2004. Gays should have equal employment rights: increased from 56% to 89% between 1977 and 2006. Gay marriage should be valid: increased from 27% to 39% between 1996 and 2005. Gays should have adoption rights: increased from 29% to 45% between 1994 and 2004. All of these questions have had ups and downs over the years, but on all of them the population has gotten steadily more gay friendly. T...

Catholic Pro-Life Obama Supporter Denied Communion

Douglas Kmiec, a former official in the Reagon Administration endorsed Barak Obama a few weeks ago. Kmiec is decidely pro-choice, but nonetheless decided that there were reasons to support Obama. Sadly, this has had reprercussions for Kmiec, a devout Catholic, as he reports: Having been drawn to Senator Obama’s remarkable “love thy neighbor” style of campaigning, his express aim to transcend partisan divide, and specifically, his appreciation for faith ("secularists are wrong when they ask believers to leave their religion at the door before entering into the public square"), I did not expect to be clobbered by co-religionists. On the blogs, I have been declared “self-excommunicated,” and recently at a Mass before a dinner speech to Catholic business leaders, a very angry college chaplain excoriated my Obama-heresy from the pulpit at length and then denied my receipt of communion. . . . Catholic voters in this circumstance are asked to consider what other social goods Oba...

Mad Priest Trinity Sermon

Image
Since I worship at Trinity Cathedral, Trinity Sunday is a very big feast day for us. The Bishop offiates, and we do conformations. And there is usually good food to be had after the service. I have therefore become very interested in the mystery of the Trinity, and found the Mad Priests' Trinity Sunday sermon this year especially useful and insightful. You really ought to read the whole thing, but here are some highlights: Nowadays, the doctrine of the Holy Trinty is still very important in Church politics. For example, a church has to hold to it to become members of the World Council of Churches. And the doctrine has also become very important in modern theology as a key to understanding relationships between Christians. But my guess is that most Christians don’t think about it much. They accept that it is something they are supposed to believe in but, being human, they still see the Father, Jesus and the Holy Spirit as three distinct individuals and relate to them as individu...

More on the California Same Sex Marriage Decision

Andrew Sullivan has a large number of excellent posts on yesterday's decision of the California Supreme Court decision on same sex marriage. Two posts, both on public opinion, merit special attention. First, for historical perspective, he notes that when the California Supreme Court decided that bans on inter-racial marriage were unconstitutional in Perez v. Sharp , public opinion was decidedly against such marriages: The California court cited the 1948 Perez v Sharp anti-miscegenation law ruling prominently in its decision today. If you believe that courts should have no role in opposing public opinion in areas of social policy, then the polls at the time make for interesting reading. Ten years after the 1948 ruling, Gallup fund that 94 percent of white Americans opposed inter-racial marriage. As late as 1967, when Loving vs Virginia was decided, a majority opposed it. That remained the case through the 1970s . In fact, the Perez v Sharp ruling was fifty years ahead of public op...

New Climate Change Study

What a coincidence. Yesterday, I blogged about the James Dobson et al "We Get It" effort to deny climate change. Yesterday, NASA scientists issued a new report showing a strong causal link between human activity and climate change. Here is the Science Daily report: A vast array of physical and biological systems across the earth are being affected by warming temperatures caused by humans, says a new analysis of information not previously assembled all in one spot. The effects on living things include earlier leafing of trees and plants over many regions; movements of species to higher latitudes and altitudes in the northern hemisphere; changes in bird migrations in Europe, North America and Australia; and shifting of the oceans' plankton and fish from cold- to warm-adapted communities. "Humans are influencing climate through increasing greenhouse gas emissions, and the warming world is causing impacts on physical and biological systems attributable at the global scal...

Gay Marriage Ban Overturned in California

Breaking News. The California Supreme Court becomes the second state supreme court to hold that the state Constitution bars a ban on same sex marriage. The New York Times has the details: The California Supreme Court has overturned a ban on gay marriage, paving the way for California to become the second state where gay and lesbian residents can marry. The justices released the 4-3 decision Thursday, saying that domestic partnerships are not a good enough substitute for marriage in an opinion written by Chief Justice Ron George. The cases were brought by the city of San Francisco, two dozen gay and lesbian couples, Equality California and another gay rights group in March 2004 after the court halted San Francisco's monthlong same-sex wedding march that took place at Mayor Gavin Newsom's direction. Read it all here . The full opinion is here . A summary of the rationale from the opinion is here: A number of factors lead us to this conclusion. First, the exclusion of same-sex cou...

They Don't Get It

Apparantly, the religious right is (once again) denying the facts--this time on the issue of global warming. They have started what appears to be a well organized and funded effort to stop efforts to attack climate change. Thanks to Melissa Rogers, here are the details: A coalition of pastors, evangelical leaders, national and state organizations, and policy makers hold a news conference on the "We Get It!" campaign, and to show "that they are united behind Biblical perspectives on the environment and the poor, and don't believe all the hype about global warming." LOCATION: National Press Club, 14th and F Streets NW, Washington, D.C. -- May 15, 2008 PARTICIPANTS: Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla.; Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla.; Rep. Paul Broun, R-Ga.; Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council; E. Calvin Beisner, founder and national spokesman for the Cornwall Alliance and Environmental Stewardship; James Tonkowich, president of the Institute on Religion and Dem...

Fraction

This is the latest from Trinity Cathedral media. There is some great stuff coming from the project, including a short video of our Cinco de Mayo celebration at the Cathedral. Check it out here .